
Running Amazon 1P and 3P Together? Keep Sell-In, Sell-Out and Inventory Separate
If you sell to Amazon as a vendor (1P) and to shoppers as a seller (3P) at the same time, you are running two businesses on one brand. Track them as three separate ledgers: sell-in (what you invoice Amazon), sell-out (what customers buy) and inventory (who owns the units and where they sit). Add them together and you double-count revenue, overstate demand and misread stock cover.

*By Rahul Bisht | Amazon Strategy | Reviewed November 2026*
Short answer: If you sell to Amazon as a vendor (1P) and to shoppers as a seller (3P) at the same time, you are running two businesses on one brand. Track them as three separate ledgers: sell-in (what you invoice Amazon), sell-out (what customers buy) and inventory (who owns the units and where they sit). Add them together and you double-count revenue, overstate demand and misread stock cover.
Table of Contents
- ●Why 1P and 3P Numbers Rarely Agree
- ●Sell-In: The Number That Pays You
- ●Sell-Out: The Number That Shows Demand
- ●Inventory: The Ledger That Causes the Real Damage
- ●A Worked Example (Hypothetical Numbers)
- ●The Four-Step Separation Routine
- ●Keep Catalog Identifiers Consistent Across Both Channels
- ●Fix the Data Pipeline, Not Just the Spreadsheet
- ●Before You Open Seller Central as an Existing Vendor
- ●Monthly Pre-Close Checklist
- ●When to Bring in Help
- ●Frequently Asked Questions
Need an Amazon expert on your side?
Work with specialists who manage PPC, SEO, catalog, and account health together — so every part of your Amazon business moves in the same direction.
Book a Call TodayWhy 1P and 3P Numbers Rarely Agree
Amazon's own guidance draws the line clearly. Seller Central is open to business owners who want to offer products to customers as third-party sellers. Vendor Central is by invitation only and is a first-party relationship in which vendors sell in bulk to Amazon, which then handles distribution.
Same brand, same ASIN, two relationships, and each one writes its own data. Brands running both often find their weekly "Amazon sales" figure changes depending on which report they open. That is not a bug. Each report answers a different question.
| Ledger | Question it answers | 1P (Vendor Central) | 3P (Seller Central) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sell-in | What did we invoice, and what will we be paid? | Purchase orders, invoices, remittance, shipped COGS | Not applicable: you sell straight to the customer |
| Sell-out | What did shoppers actually buy? | Retail Analytics: ordered revenue, shipped revenue, units | Orders, settlements and sales reports |
| Inventory | Who owns the units, where are they, how long will they last? | Amazon-owned stock after PO receipt | Your FBA, FBM and inbound stock |
Need an Amazon expert on your side?
Work with specialists who manage PPC, SEO, catalog, and account health together — so every part of your Amazon business moves in the same direction.
Book a Call TodaySell-In: The Number That Pays You
Vendor sales reporting separates several measures: ordered revenue, shipped revenue, shipped units and shipped COGS. Shipped COGS reflects Amazon's cost to buy the units it shipped, which makes it the closest proxy for your own wholesale revenue. Shipped revenue reflects retail value, which is Amazon's income, not yours.
Amazon has kept adding to this data. Its Data Kiosk Vendor Analytics dataset added shippedCogs and contraCOGS metrics in December 2024, which matters if you pull vendor data into your own reporting.
So when someone says "Amazon sold $28,000 of our product this month," ask which number they mean.
Sell-Out: The Number That Shows Demand
Sell-out is what shoppers actually bought. On 1P it comes from shipped or ordered revenue and units. On 3P it comes from your own orders and settlements.
Two cautions apply.
Pick One Revenue Basis and Keep It
Ordered figures can move after the order date because orders can be cancelled before they ship. Shipped figures are more settled.
Check the Reporting View
Vendor reports can be viewed on a manufacturing or sourcing basis. They answer different questions, so choose deliberately and label every export.
Sell-out is also where the channels most often get blended by accident. A dashboard that sums 1P shipped revenue and 3P sales mixes retail value on one side with your own revenue on the other.
Need an Amazon expert on your side?
Work with specialists who manage PPC, SEO, catalog, and account health together — so every part of your Amazon business moves in the same direction.
Book a Call TodayInventory: The Ledger That Causes the Real Damage
The two pools behave differently.
1P Stock
It is bought by Amazon on a purchase order. Your levers are the next PO, your forecast and your vendor relationship.
3P FBA Stock
It is yours until a customer buys it. You decide when to replenish, you carry storage cost, and you carry stockout risk.
Inbound, FBM and Warehouse Stock
It sits outside both pools and still belongs in your plan.
Amazon's own FBA guidance is built around this seller-owned model. It flags that too little stock disappoints customers and too much raises storage costs, and that unbalanced inventory can lower your Inventory Performance Index (IPI) score. Amazon also treats stock above 90 days of supply as excess. None of that applies to units Amazon already owns under 1P.
Merge both pools into one "Amazon inventory" number and you hide the pool that is actually about to run out.
Need an Amazon expert on your side?
Work with specialists who manage PPC, SEO, catalog, and account health together — so every part of your Amazon business moves in the same direction.
Book a Call TodayA Worked Example (Hypothetical Numbers)
These figures are illustrative, to show the mechanics. Your prices, terms and volumes will differ.
"Northfield Home" sells one ASIN on both 1P and 3P. One 30-day month:
| Item | 1P (Vendor Central) | 3P (Seller Central, FBA) |
|---|---|---|
| Opening stock | 500 units (Amazon-owned) | 400 units (yours) |
| Received / inbound | 2,000 units (one PO) | 500 units |
| Units sold to shoppers | 1,400 | 600 |
| Retail price | $20 | $20 |
| Wholesale cost to Amazon | $12 | n/a |
| Closing stock | 1,100 | 300 |
- ●Sell-in (1P only): 2,000 units × $12 = $24,000 invoiced to Amazon.
- ●Sell-out: 1P 1,400 × $20 = $28,000 at retail; 3P 600 × $20 = $12,000. Total consumer demand = 2,000 units, $40,000.
- ●Shipped COGS (1P): 1,400 × $12 = $16,800, what Amazon's sales of your units are worth to you at wholesale.
Where It Goes Wrong
- ●Add sell-in ($24,000) to sell-out ($40,000) and you get $64,000, which is double-counted and means nothing.
- ●Add the closing stock of both pools and you get 1,400 units. Total weekly sell-out is about 467 units, so the blended view says roughly 3 weeks of cover. That looks acceptable.
- ●Split it. 1P has 1,100 units against about 327 per week, or about 3.4 weeks. 3P has 300 units against about 140 per week, or about 2.1 weeks. The pool you pay to restock is the one at risk, and the blended number hid it. Amazon notes that being unable to keep popular items in stock can also pull down your IPI score.
Sell-through for the month (the brand's own formula): units sold ÷ (opening stock + units received). For 1P that is 1,400 ÷ (500 + 2,000) = 56%. Be aware that definitions differ. Amazon defines FBA sell-through as units sold and delivered over the past 90 days divided by the average sellable units in fulfilment centres. Whichever formula you use, write it down and apply it consistently.
One brand, one ASIN, three different stories. That is the case for separate ledgers.
Need an Amazon expert on your side?
Work with specialists who manage PPC, SEO, catalog, and account health together — so every part of your Amazon business moves in the same direction.
Book a Call TodayThe Four-Step Separation Routine
Step 1: Tag Every Record by Channel at Source
Every export, sheet row and dashboard field carries a channel label (1P or 3P) and a basis label (ordered, shipped or settled).
Step 2: Report the Three Ledgers Side by Side and Never Sum Across Them
Sell-in belongs to finance, sell-out to marketing and category teams, inventory to supply chain.
Step 3: Forecast Each Pool on Its Own
1P forecasts feed PO conversations. 3P forecasts feed replenishment and FBA shipment planning. Our guide to stockout-censored demand explains why a stockout can make demand look lower than it really is, which matters most on the pool that ran out.
Step 4: Reconcile Monthly
Tie 1P sell-in to invoices and remittances, 3P sell-out to settlements, and both inventory pools to system or physical counts.
Keep Catalog Identifiers Consistent Across Both Channels
Both channels sell against the same catalog. If single units, multipacks and bundles are not mapped consistently, 1P and 3P can end up pointing at different identifiers for what you think of as one product, and the reports will not line up. A Packaging Master gives you one reference sheet for what each sellable item contains and which identifier belongs to it.
Fix the Data Pipeline, Not Just the Spreadsheet
If your 1P and 3P figures flow through APIs or an ERP, missing report days and late events quietly distort all three ledgers. Our SP-API replay and backfill runbook shows how to find and repair those gaps before they reach a dashboard. If your vendor side relies on EDI, Amazon EDI and ERP integration keeps sell-in clean at the source.
Before You Open Seller Central as an Existing Vendor
Terms and expectations can differ by category, region and relationship, so confirm with your vendor manager before assuming either way. Amazon allows sellers with an existing Vendor Central, Brand Registry or Amazon Ads login to use the same credentials for Seller Central if they want synced access, but your vendor agreement still governs the 1P side.
Monthly Pre-Close Checklist
☐ Every report row is labelled 1P or 3P ☐ Every revenue figure states its basis: ordered, shipped or settled ☐ Sell-in ties to invoices and remittances ☐ No ledger is summed with another ☐ Weeks of cover are calculated per pool, not blended ☐ Sell-through uses one written formula and one period ☐ Identifier mapping checked for new multipacks and bundles ☐ Data gaps (missing days, late events) logged and backfilled
When to Bring in Help
If that checklist feels like a full-time job, the hybrid model has probably outgrown spreadsheets. GrowithAmazon runs both sides: Vendor Central management for purchase orders, chargebacks and shortage claims, Seller Central management for 3P operations, and marketplace intelligence to bring the three ledgers into one reporting view without merging them.
Ready to Build Your Next Amazon Success Story?
If you're facing low sales, rising ACOS, inventory challenges, or declining performance, our Amazon agency can help. Book a free strategy consultation and discover the opportunities that can transform your business.
Frequently Asked Questions
Answers to the most common questions about this topic.
1. What is the Amazon hybrid model?
2. What is the difference between sell-in and sell-out on Amazon?
3. Why shouldn't I add 1P and 3P revenue together?
4. What is shipped COGS in Vendor Central?
5. How do I track inventory across 1P and 3P?
6. How is Amazon sell-through calculated?
Sources
Explore the latest Amazon insights, content, and optimization guides trending with sellers in 2026.
Written by Rahul Bisht
Related Articles
Amazon Strategy
Late Amazon SP-API Events and Missing Report Days: A Complete Replay and Backfill Runbook
Amazon Strategy
Stockout-Censored Demand: Why Your Amazon Reorder Forecast Is Underestimating Actual Demand
Amazon Strategy
Single Unit, Multipack or Bundle? Prevent Amazon Product Identifier Mismatches With a Packaging Master
Free Amazon Audit
We respond within 24 hours.